Centre-State Financial Relations 2027 — Finance Commission, GST Council and UPSC GS2 Analysis
Centre-State Financial Relations is a high-weightage topic in UPSC Mains GS2 (Indian Polity) and every State PCS examination. The chapter covers constitutional provisions for tax devolution, the Finance Commission’s role, GST Council functioning, grants-in-aid, and ongoing debates about fiscal federalism in India. Every UPSC Mains aspirant must master this chapter because questions on Finance Commission recommendations, devolution controversies, and GST disputes appear almost every year. This comprehensive guide covers all you need for 2027 exams.
Constitutional Framework: Key Articles
| Article | Subject | Significance |
|---|---|---|
| Article 270 | Taxes levied and distributed between Union and States | Core tax-sharing provision |
| Article 271 | Surcharges on certain duties and taxes | Parliament can levy surcharges — not shared with states |
| Article 275 | Grants from Union to certain States | Revenue deficit grants, special category grants |
| Article 280 | Finance Commission | Establishes FC; determines Centre-State share of taxes |
| Article 281 | Recommendations of Finance Commission | FC recommendations placed before each House |
| Article 246 | Subject matter of laws by Parliament and State Legislature | Union, State, Concurrent Lists |
| Article 263 | Inter-State Council | Coordination body for Centre-State disputes |
| Article 301 | Freedom of trade, commerce and intercourse | Restrictions on inter-state trade barriers |
| Article 293 | Borrowing by States | States cannot borrow from external sources without Centre consent |
Finance Commission of India
Constitutional Basis
The Finance Commission is a constitutional body established under Article 280. It is set up every five years (or earlier if needed) to recommend:
- The distribution of divisible pool of taxes between Centre and States (vertical devolution)
- The inter se allocation among states (horizontal devolution)
- Principles governing grants-in-aid to states
- Any other matter referred to by the President
15th Finance Commission (2021–26)
- Chairman: N.K. Singh
- Devolution to States: 41% of divisible pool (same as 14th FC; 1% reduced from 42% after Jammu and Kashmir bifurcation)
- Key recommendations: Revenue deficit grants to 17 states; performance-based grants (Health, Education, Agriculture); disaster risk management grants
- Controversy: South Indian states (Kerala, Karnataka, TN) argued formula disadvantages states with better demographic performance
Vertical vs Horizontal Devolution
- Vertical devolution: What share of total divisible pool goes to states vs Centre (currently 41%)
- Horizontal devolution: How the 41% is distributed among 28 states + UTs with legislatures
Horizontal Devolution Criteria (15th FC)
| Criterion | Weight |
|---|---|
| Income distance (fiscal need) | 45% |
| Population (2011 Census) | 15% |
| Area | 15% |
| Forest and ecology | 10% |
| Demographic performance | 12.5% |
| Tax effort | 2.5% |
GST Council
Constitutional Basis
GST Council was established under Article 279A inserted by the 101st Constitutional Amendment Act, 2016. It is a joint forum of the Centre and States.
Composition
- Chairperson: Union Finance Minister
- Vice-Chairperson: State Finance Minister (elected)
- Members: Finance Ministers of all states/UTs with legislature
Decision-Making
- Decisions by 3/4 majority of votes cast
- Centre has 1/3 of votes; all states together have 2/3
- Quorum: 50% of total membership
GST Council: Key Disputes (UPSC-relevant)
- Kerala vs Centre (2021): SC held GST Council recommendations are persuasive, NOT binding — states have legislative competence on GST
- Compensation cess dispute (2020–22): States demanded compensation for revenue shortfall; Centre argued COVID was an “Act of God”; extended compensation till 2026
- Rate rationalization debates: Ongoing between Centre (revenue maximization) and states (political compulsions)
Grants-in-Aid (Article 275)
Under Article 275, Parliament may grant aid from the Consolidated Fund of India to such states as Parliament determines. Types of grants:
Want structured UPSC preparation? Try our free Free Demo Course with live classes and expert guidance. Start Free →
- Statutory grants: Recommended by Finance Commission; legally mandated
- Discretionary grants: Given by Planning Commission/NITI Aayog for specific schemes; states argue these are more conditioned
- Revenue deficit grants: 15th FC gives to 17 states with projected revenue deficits post-devolution
Key Commissions and Reports on Centre-State Relations
| Commission/Report | Year | Key Recommendations |
|---|---|---|
| Sarkaria Commission | 1983 | Strengthen federalism; Inter-State Council must be activated; Article 356 sparingly used |
| M.M. Punchhi Commission | 2010 | Reviewed Sarkaria recommendations; recommended constitutional safeguards for Centre-State harmony |
| NITI Aayog vs Planning Commission | 2015 | Plan grants replaced by devolution; states now have more fiscal autonomy theoretically |
10 Practice MCQs — Centre-State Financial Relations
Quiz data missing.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
- Q: What is the Finance Commission and what does it do?
- Constitutional body under Article 280, constituted every 5 years. Recommends vertical devolution (currently 41% of divisible pool to states), horizontal allocation among states, grants-in-aid principles, and other fiscal matters referred by the President.
- Q: How does GST Council take decisions?
- 3/4 majority of votes cast. Centre = 1/3 votes; all states together = 2/3. 2021 SC ruling: GST Council recommendations are persuasive, not binding — Parliament and state legislatures retain legislative competence.
- Q: What was controversial about 15th Finance Commission formula?
- South Indian states argued they were penalized for better demographic performance — lower fertility rates reduced their population-based share. They termed it “punishment for good governance.”
- Q: Difference between Article 275 and Article 280 grants?
- Article 280 establishes Finance Commission (recommends tax devolution). Article 275 provides statutory grants-in-aid — revenue deficit grants and purpose-specific grants. Unlike discretionary executive grants (central schemes), Article 275 grants are constitutionally mandated.
Prepare for UPSC GS2 with Civils Gyani’s comprehensive UPSC coaching and free UPSC mock tests.
